alfie wrote:But the idea that four experienced international bowlers had no knowledge of the fact that serious monkey business was being carried out on the ball : don't make me laugh !
Actually, there was a fifth international bowler present on the field, someone who has been involved in about 7 ICC Finals as a player and an umpire, and who's experience counts for nearly a combined 2000 professional games, which I imagine would put him somewhere near, or at the very top of, a list of most experienced people ever involved in a cricket match. Throw in he is an elite ICC umpire with expert training and tools to judge the situation at hand, and its arguable you couldnt find a single person in the world who had the capacity to make a more informed judgement of the situation. Richard Illingworth held that ball in his hands, and concluded the ball had not changed state to any degree that aroused suspicion or warrant further action to change it.
This is not heresay, its 100% fact. A highly trained, highly competent neutral observer made an assessment that fully corroborates the view that the ball had visually not changed. Any argument made in the counter replaces facts decided by experts, and substitutes it for unevidenced heresay. This point is not controversial in the least, its just 100% factual. Its what literally happened.
