by alfie » Sat Aug 08, 2020 6:11 am
I am always reluctant to discuss selection while a match is still in progress...events can make one look a bit silly.
But : I largely agree with DFM. A proper number three - Crawley , since Denly has left the bubble - thus allowing Root/Stokes/Pope to play as the engine room at 4-6 , is really the most important change (Stokes seems fit enough to bowl !)
However I have a nagging fear that Buttler's horror days keeping to Bess might lead to his having to relinquish the gloves to Foakes...and , given Ed Smith's project priority , that this would then lead to re-installing Jos as the number six bat ; with the knock on effect being no Crawley , and either Root and Stokes remaining in their present (unsuitable) positions or Pope being prematurely elevated to three. I do not think that would be a good idea but can we not all see it happening ?
As to the bowlers I suspect wear and tear will be a main consideration. Broad and Woakes are the clear form men at present , but , as West Indies found out , sometimes you need to give your stars a rest or they won't last the distance. If they are considered OK , they both play for me and worry about match three later ; but no doubt the medical staff will have an input. Archer looks to me in need of a rest - he's not bowling at ninety , and Wood is well rested if they are desperate for real pace. Jimmy has looked oddly out of sorts in this game , though he's not had the best of luck in his new ball spells ; and Curran waits in the wings. As long as Stokes takes no harm from his slightly surprising intervention late yesterday and is fit to bowl I reckon any combination of three fast bowlers and a spinner could be viable , to be honest.
But if they don't get the batting sorted out it might not matter much what they do with the bowlers. The attempt to chase down (260 ?) will be interesting...