Having cooled off somewhat after a night of sleep I can address that second day as calmly as possible....
Very disappointing to see England once again follow a good - or at least decent - first day with a total trainwreck on the second. OK , batting conditions were probably slightly better than the previous day , and you have to give credit to Australia's top four ... but still too much was made easy for them by some dreadful bowling and an epidemic of dropped catches.
Wasn't good from the start. After reaching 334 you'd have thought the bowlers would be up and at them from the off ; but Archer started as if he was having a net warm up - low 130s and all over the shop to give Head a comfortable couple of overs to just watch the ball go by. He got going later and produced some good stuff - and was dead unlucky with Smith's bad drop of Head ; but honestly taking three overs to get into gear when you are going to be used in 4/5 over spells is just not acceptable. At least he put in some solid work later in the day and was again rather let down by his fielders ; but it is becoming past time for him to produce the sort of performance in Tests that he did in his initial debut series , and which everyone seems to assume he still has in him. Otherwise might be best to just stick to white ball stuff.
Atkinson started well - and I think he was the most consistent of the bowlers , rather unlucky to remain wicketless. But he seemed to wilt in that first spell when Weatherald got after him and was consequently removed rather quickly from the attack : he badly needs to get onto the wicket column or his confidence is likely to tank. His early removal brought Carse on and oh boy did he serve up some rubbish ! Got Head going , score rocketing , whole game plan out the window ... OK he ended up getting the break but that was Head losing his ...head. Two more fortunate wickets late on but doesn't mask the fact that he is consistently offering runs on a plate. For whatever reason , he seems to have completely lost his bowling form over the last few months.
Stokes was mixed. Also far too many loose balls but at least he produced a couple of big wickets : I fear the failures of the others are putting a lot of strain on his body though as he feels compelled to keep digging deep for his side heedless of the danger to his fitness. Lose him and they might as well head for the airport.
Could Jacks have been tried ? Couldn't have cost more than Carse I suppose , though I don't think there is anything in this surface for a spinner : Australia leaving out Lyon was a bit of a clue. At least he partially justified his place with a brilliant catch !
Remarkable thing is that despite the largely rotten bowling (so much short and wide of the body !) England were still well in it in that last session - due mainly to Australian bats showing England don't have a monopoly on daft get out shots : Cam Green what were you thinking ? If they could catch this innings might be all but over with a modest lead ... but four easy chances missed - and one very hard one to Root , which arguably should have been more easily taken by the keeper ? But Smith was flat footed and motionless...he is having a bit of a shocker.
In fact those first innings ducks seem to have infected all of them : Duckett , Smith , Carse all dropping catches . Nothing flew near Pope yet
So what's the prognosis ? Australia 44 ahead already , these two can bat - and Starc in next can hit the ball so a chance to get the lead over 100 ; though the new ball isn't far off. Bowlers will be tired but they absolutely have to limit the damage by getting these remaining wickets as cheaply as possible. Then over to the bats to see if they can actually achieve an 80 over innings for once : if they can then all would not be lost as you'd imagine the cracks in the pitch will start to play some part over the last couple of days.
15 years ago on this ground England responded to a huge first innings deficit by making 517/1 ... and we all remember what that led to . Unfortunately they don't have a Strauss Cook Trott top three this time around so might need a bit more of a team effort !
Forecast suggests some chance of storms and more than a dash of rain Sunday/Monday so a draw isn't out of the question ; but I don't expect the sort of washout that Manchester generally produces when England look good for a win at home ; so up to the batsmen to bail themselves out. Will continue to hope because I really don't want to watch a bunch of dead rubber matches this time around.
But a lot less hopeful than 24 hours ago
