by sussexpob » Thu Dec 26, 2024 5:30 pm
Far more worrying in my opinion is that for a second time this series, a player is hit on the pad while moving down the pitch, and hawkeye makes a clear error on the ball tracking of it.
The Comms didn't pick it up, but look at the Siraj ball to Khawaja right at the start of the innings. When Khawaja is hit on the pad, you can see the ball hits him almost perfectly on the middle of the knee roll, bat is pointing straight down the pitch mms from the ball, Khawaja's head is down and straight looking at the ball, and his front foot is planted just a toes length outside from the large worn patch on the pitch to judge how far down he is....cut to the hawkeye decision, Khawaja has his head looking at slip, bat is angled and miles away from the pad, and his front foot is now completely outside the worn patch on the pitch.....
Hakweye clearly superimposed the position of Khawaja sometime AFTER he was struck (looking at the replay 1-2 seconds after) to judge where he was hit, and not actually his position when he was hit. The ball tracking therefore concludes that he was hit well above the knee roll, probably 1 balls diameter if not more were the naked eye can clearly see he was hit... its not even close to be accurate. This makes sense, because Khawaja is moving forward when he is hit, and takes 2 steps further down the pitch with his momentum after contact, so using this "final position" as a judge of his body position in line with the flight of the ball, they have in essence made it look like he was hit further up on the pad.
Considering the ball scrapes the stumps on hawkeye, its an error that appears to have cost India a wicket. Don't think we can even debate its a mistake, its pretty unambiguous and totally obvious if you check the replay. Khawaja's body position is clearly from the future.
2010 French Open fantasy league guru 2010 Wimbledon fantasy league guru 2014 Masters golf fantasy guru 2015 Players Championship FL Guru 2016 Masters Golf Fantasy Guru
And a hat and bra to you too, my good sirs!