alfie wrote:I'd expect Bethell to be a bit up and down at this early stage of his International career , though the talent is obviously there. Not really sure number three is his right spot though - in any format. Perhaps the order might be shuffled a little : Banton and Brook moving up one each ? He also brings a useful extra spin option so surely a better bet than Duckett on recent form , no ?
England are somewhat hamstrung by their own selection, as they have picked 6 all-rounders and almost zero specialist batting cover in the squad. I guess the thinking behind that is they want small cameos across the lineup rather than rely on big innings at the top, and to be fair that is one way to win in T20Is so it might be shrewd.... But with Curran batting at 6 recently, I think you have to sacrifice a bowling allrounder to play every single top order bat you have, irrespective of form.
I would personally go Salt, Buttler, Duckett, Brook, Banton, Bethell, Curran..... and if they stick to a similar team as recently, I would rotate Overton and Jacks based on conditions. I don't really understand Jacks being there at the moment, he only bowls if the pitch is a total bunsen (at which point you have other options), and a handful of lower order runs at the bottom hardly feels efficient...
As an example he played one game last series where he didn't field or bat.... he's that type of pick. If he's batting, you are in trouble. If he's bowling, you are in trouble.